Review NaN of 6
Price Paid:
$60.00
from www.replay.nl Summary: "UBISOFT's SC:PT 'CELLS OUT',...A BIT."
SC: PT has nice new gameplay
additions but SC1 is imo, overall
more memorable and of better quality.
Don't get me wrong please, SC:PT is
still a superb game, but there are
clear signs of alterations in PT,
that Ubi tried to cater more to 'mainstream' gamers ; which kind of hurts the game, really.
Some examples ;
- jungle levels : while it seems to be the trend in games, the trademark SC gameplay is way better in tight urban levels where it belongs. The visibility
system is too often questionable 2 be considered as 'realistic' in those open jungles. While the vegetation looks great, it's still a very lineair path.
- FRAMERATE : while SC1 wasn't ultra perfect, PT's framerate is more prone to framedrops. It hoovers about 10 to 15 frames less than SC1 due to increased geometry and FX.
- ANIMATIONS : the lack of Steve Dupont's
(lead animator Ubisoft Montreal) animating skills is felt in PT, some new moves just look a bit more mechanical. Add to that a slightly lesser framerate and it then it really shows.
- NO improved AI. : while the guard's senses have been sharpened a bit, they still are a bit dumb. It's also disappointing to see that they don't have aggressive search and destroy teams which hunt you down once you've been caught like in the MGS games. This wouldn't be a problem if Sam could only take 1 or 2 hits, but now, it's just to easy and unrealistic. They now even employ this 3 stage alert system 'normal-flak jackets-helmets' protocol which in fact is a 3 stadium buffer system to 'forgive' the helpless mainstream gamer for his screwups.
- Various automated gameplay handlings : stuff like handling a door. Immediately you have 2 choose 'open door' or 'use optic cable'. While this may be convenient for the mainstream gamer, this feels very arcady. The same goes for the goggles which feature binocular function as well.
- Voice acting : the new Lambert sounds too artificial and Grimsdottir too forced strict and serious. The worst : the lack of cheesy foreign accents on npc's. While this may seems like a minor point, imo it was a very charming touch to the SC1 game. It just sounds wrong to hear Indonesians talk like Americans.
Despite these gripes, I enjoy SC:PT alot. Imo, the best levels are Jerusalem, Paris and Jakarta.
The cutscenes are polished and entertaining, and Sam get some nice character development. It's a little sad to see they are trying to alter his face a bit becuz imo his 'Clooney' look was very cool in SC1. Also, imo Sam's new jungle suit just looks NOT cool. All in all I would give SC: PT a 8.9 out of 10 whereas i give SC1 a 9.2 out of 10 (my favourite game Ico, my #1 scores 9.5 out of 10 on my favs list) Report this review >>
|